No, my first instinct would be to fight back and knock them unconscious, not strangle them. You seriously think it's justifiable for someone to try killing someone who punched you in the face and caused you a minor injury? That's bullshit.

Well, did you bother asking him why he got stabbed, or did you ask if he's done anything that someone might want revenge for? Just curious what bases you've covered. I mean sure, my inmate attacked yours, yours fought back, mine stabbed yours, yours tried to strangle mine, they're both clearly at fault here, but at least Costigan had a reason I support. What's Armand's? Because sorry, "memory loss" and "self defense" don't cover trying to kill someone.

And just to be clear, I could honestly care less about warden harmony right now. Costigan's well being is more important to me then you feeling like I don't care about the guy who tried to kill someone I care about.